 Issue Data
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Issue #32481: Restricted outfits for pre-gen settlers.
Related Issues: 27802
I don't think the leveled items in the outfits mentioned by 27802 are intended to produce a "variety" of outfits. There is an important distinction: Armor_Wastelander_01_GlovesA (Radstag Hide Outfit), Armor_Wastelander_02_NoHood_GlovesB (Scavenger Outfit), and Armor_Wastelander_02_Hood_GlovesB (Explorer Outfit) all prevent armor pieces from being worn over them, whereas the clothing items in the leveled list LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear (Athletic Outfit, Undershirt & Jeans, and Flannel Shirt and Jeans) all allow a full set of armor to be worn over them.
More likely, the "underwear" clothing was intended to provide a fallback in case the player wants to equip the settler with armor pieces, but since that ends up as the second item in the "outfit" list (and there doesn't seem to be a way to re-order the list), it gets worn instead of the radstag hide or explorer outfit.
As far as a "greater variety of outfits", it doesn't seem that way to me - maybe 3 from that leveled instead of mostly 2 (according to FO4Edit references there are 78 NPCs who wear the outfit that gives the Radstag Hide Outfit, 24 who wear the outfit that gives the Scavenger Outfit, and only 7 who get the Explorer Outfit). By disabling UFO4P, the settlers you mention randomly wear the Athletic Outfit, Undershirt & Jeans, or Flannel Shirt and Jeans instead. Checking Tenpines Bluff, Greentop Nursery, Somerville Place, Warwick Homestead, Finch Farm, The Slog, County Crossing, and Oberland Station, I only saw one adult wearing a different outfit beyond those three: Roger Warwick, because he uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A] instead of one of the three outfits mentioned in the other bug.
More likely, the "underwear" clothing was intended to provide a fallback in case the player wants to equip the settler with armor pieces, but since that ends up as the second item in the "outfit" list (and there doesn't seem to be a way to re-order the list), it gets worn instead of the radstag hide or explorer outfit.
As far as a "greater variety of outfits", it doesn't seem that way to me - maybe 3 from that leveled instead of mostly 2 (according to FO4Edit references there are 78 NPCs who wear the outfit that gives the Radstag Hide Outfit, 24 who wear the outfit that gives the Scavenger Outfit, and only 7 who get the Explorer Outfit). By disabling UFO4P, the settlers you mention randomly wear the Athletic Outfit, Undershirt & Jeans, or Flannel Shirt and Jeans instead. Checking Tenpines Bluff, Greentop Nursery, Somerville Place, Warwick Homestead, Finch Farm, The Slog, County Crossing, and Oberland Station, I only saw one adult wearing a different outfit beyond those three: Roger Warwick, because he uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A] instead of one of the three outfits mentioned in the other bug.
Have done a bit more testing, having found another location where it is easier to see whats happening.
coc CambridgeKendallHospital01
Where there are 8 corpses of Railroad Agents.
Vanilla without UFO4: all eight have a random selection of Athletic Outfit, Flannel Shirt and Jeans and Undershirt & Jeans (worn). They also all have Radstag Hide Outfits in thier inventory (not equipped). (The Radstag Hide Outfits would appear to be a bug)
Vanilla with UFO4: all eight only have Radstag Hide Outfits (worn). (This would also appear to be a bug)
It really starts becomig obvious once you start using any mod that adds clothing to the lists (Eli's Armour Compendium for my testing).
Without UFO4, settlers and deceased railroad agents pull from the Athletic/Flannel Shirt and Jeans/Undershirt & Jeans/something from Eli's equipped (and once again Radstag Hide/Explorers/Surveyors oufits in thier inventories).
With UFO4 its Radstag Hide Outfits, Surveyors Outfits or Explorers outfits only (unless you are a dead railroad agent, in which case its Radstag Hide only, it seems).
coc CambridgeKendallHospital01
Where there are 8 corpses of Railroad Agents.
Vanilla without UFO4: all eight have a random selection of Athletic Outfit, Flannel Shirt and Jeans and Undershirt & Jeans (worn). They also all have Radstag Hide Outfits in thier inventory (not equipped). (The Radstag Hide Outfits would appear to be a bug)
Vanilla with UFO4: all eight only have Radstag Hide Outfits (worn). (This would also appear to be a bug)
It really starts becomig obvious once you start using any mod that adds clothing to the lists (Eli's Armour Compendium for my testing).
Without UFO4, settlers and deceased railroad agents pull from the Athletic/Flannel Shirt and Jeans/Undershirt & Jeans/something from Eli's equipped (and once again Radstag Hide/Explorers/Surveyors oufits in thier inventories).
With UFO4 its Radstag Hide Outfits, Surveyors Outfits or Explorers outfits only (unless you are a dead railroad agent, in which case its Radstag Hide only, it seems).
Let me check the NPCs at several pre-settled farms in xEdit:
Abernathy Farm:
Blake - uses ResidentFarmhand [OTFT:000E7475], which is just ClothesResident3 "Farmhand Clothes" [ARMO:000E5084]
Connie - uses ResidentGenericJumpsuit [OTFT:001C409D], which is just ClothesGenericJumpsuit "Mechanic Jumpsuit" [ARMO:001C26B9]
Lucy - uses ResidentFlannelShirtAndJeans [OTFT:0014D254], which is just Armor_Rustic_Underarmor "Flannel Shirt and Jeans" [ARMO:00117EB9]
Finch Farm:
Abigail - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842], which is Armor_Wastelander_01_GlovesA "Radstag Hide Outfit" [ARMO:00034595] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Abraham - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A], which is LL_Wastelander_Outfit [LVLI:001C2699] (at least 11 choices)
Daniel - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D], which is Armor_Wastelander_02_NoHood_GlovesB "Scavenger Outfit" [ARMO:000732AE] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Jake - uses ResidentSurveyor [OTFT:000DC93C], which is just ClothesResident5 "Surveyor Outfit" [ARMO:000B3F4C]
The Slog:
Arlen Glass - uses ResidentFarmhand [OTFT:000E7475]
Deirdre - uses Wastelander02withHood [OTFT:0002186E], which is Armor_Wastelander_02_Hood_GlovesB "Explorer Outfit" [ARMO:000732AC] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Holly - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Jones - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
Wiseman - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Worker 1 - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A]
Worker 2 - uses WorkerSlogOutfit02 [OTFT:002486EE], which is Armor_Wastelander_01_GlovesA "Radstag Hide Outfit" [ARMO:00034595], LL_Armor_Piecemeal_ArmRight [LVLI:0007BB11], ClothesVisor "Faded Visor" [ARMO:0012571C], ClothesBlackRimGlasses "Black-Rim Glasses" [ARMO:00125891], and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] (confusing combination here - the radstag hide outfit conflicts with both the right-arm armor and the "underwear" clothing)
Worker 3 - uses WorkerSlogOutfit03 [OTFT:002486EF], which is ClothesDog_DogCollar "Dog Collar" [ARMO:00034602], Clothes_Raider_SurgicalMask "Surgical Mask" [ARMO:000787DA], LL_Armor_Piecemeal_LegLeft [LVLI:0007BB12], ClothesWinterHat "Ushanka Hat" [ARMO:000F6D83], and ClothesTattered "Tattered Rags" [ARMO:0011609B]
Warwick Homestead:
Bill Sutton - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
Janey - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
June - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Roger - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A]
Wally - uses ChildOutfitStripedShirtAndJeans [OTFT:001681B5], which is ClothesKids01 "Kid's Shirt and Jeans" [ARMO:00167A75]
7 out of 20 use clearly non-randomized outfits, 10 out of 20 use outfits that might have been intended as mostly non-random (Wastelander01/02/02WithHood, and WorkerSlogOutfit02), and only 3 of those 20 use the deliberately random "WastelanderOutfit": Abraham Finch, Roger Warwick, and WorkerSlog1 "Worker" [NPC_:000F8F28]. If I just look at the different outfits used by settlers, ignoring how many NPCs use them, the leveled "underwear" items added to Wastelander01, Wastelander02, and Wastelander02WithHood would seem to be the exception more than the rule. After this investigation, I'm not so sure 27802 should be reverted (though I'm not the one with the final say on that).
As far as the corpses at Kendall Hospital, those are Railroad Agent corpses, not pre-gen settlers, so that might be a separate bug to file. IMO, it would make more sense for those corpses to be using RailroadHQOutfit [OTFT:001344E9] as their default outfit instead of Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Abernathy Farm:
Blake - uses ResidentFarmhand [OTFT:000E7475], which is just ClothesResident3 "Farmhand Clothes" [ARMO:000E5084]
Connie - uses ResidentGenericJumpsuit [OTFT:001C409D], which is just ClothesGenericJumpsuit "Mechanic Jumpsuit" [ARMO:001C26B9]
Lucy - uses ResidentFlannelShirtAndJeans [OTFT:0014D254], which is just Armor_Rustic_Underarmor "Flannel Shirt and Jeans" [ARMO:00117EB9]
Finch Farm:
Abigail - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842], which is Armor_Wastelander_01_GlovesA "Radstag Hide Outfit" [ARMO:00034595] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Abraham - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A], which is LL_Wastelander_Outfit [LVLI:001C2699] (at least 11 choices)
Daniel - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D], which is Armor_Wastelander_02_NoHood_GlovesB "Scavenger Outfit" [ARMO:000732AE] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Jake - uses ResidentSurveyor [OTFT:000DC93C], which is just ClothesResident5 "Surveyor Outfit" [ARMO:000B3F4C]
The Slog:
Arlen Glass - uses ResidentFarmhand [OTFT:000E7475]
Deirdre - uses Wastelander02withHood [OTFT:0002186E], which is Armor_Wastelander_02_Hood_GlovesB "Explorer Outfit" [ARMO:000732AC] (and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] if UFO4P is not installed)
Holly - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Jones - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
Wiseman - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Worker 1 - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A]
Worker 2 - uses WorkerSlogOutfit02 [OTFT:002486EE], which is Armor_Wastelander_01_GlovesA "Radstag Hide Outfit" [ARMO:00034595], LL_Armor_Piecemeal_ArmRight [LVLI:0007BB11], ClothesVisor "Faded Visor" [ARMO:0012571C], ClothesBlackRimGlasses "Black-Rim Glasses" [ARMO:00125891], and LL_Clothing_Settler_Underwear [LVLI:001AC0B8] (confusing combination here - the radstag hide outfit conflicts with both the right-arm armor and the "underwear" clothing)
Worker 3 - uses WorkerSlogOutfit03 [OTFT:002486EF], which is ClothesDog_DogCollar "Dog Collar" [ARMO:00034602], Clothes_Raider_SurgicalMask "Surgical Mask" [ARMO:000787DA], LL_Armor_Piecemeal_LegLeft [LVLI:0007BB12], ClothesWinterHat "Ushanka Hat" [ARMO:000F6D83], and ClothesTattered "Tattered Rags" [ARMO:0011609B]
Warwick Homestead:
Bill Sutton - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
Janey - uses Wastelander02 [OTFT:0002184D]
June - uses Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Roger - uses WastelanderOutfit [OTFT:001C269A]
Wally - uses ChildOutfitStripedShirtAndJeans [OTFT:001681B5], which is ClothesKids01 "Kid's Shirt and Jeans" [ARMO:00167A75]
7 out of 20 use clearly non-randomized outfits, 10 out of 20 use outfits that might have been intended as mostly non-random (Wastelander01/02/02WithHood, and WorkerSlogOutfit02), and only 3 of those 20 use the deliberately random "WastelanderOutfit": Abraham Finch, Roger Warwick, and WorkerSlog1 "Worker" [NPC_:000F8F28]. If I just look at the different outfits used by settlers, ignoring how many NPCs use them, the leveled "underwear" items added to Wastelander01, Wastelander02, and Wastelander02WithHood would seem to be the exception more than the rule. After this investigation, I'm not so sure 27802 should be reverted (though I'm not the one with the final say on that).
As far as the corpses at Kendall Hospital, those are Railroad Agent corpses, not pre-gen settlers, so that might be a separate bug to file. IMO, it would make more sense for those corpses to be using RailroadHQOutfit [OTFT:001344E9] as their default outfit instead of Wastelander01 [OTFT:00021842]
Showing Comments 1 - 3 of 3