Welcome to the AFK Mods bug tracker. In order to report an issue, please select a project from the drop down menu below. Select “Open New Issue” and fill out the form with as many details as possible.

An account will be required to submit an issue, so if you need one and are unable to register, please contact us via the forums at https://www.afkmods.com/

Issue Data
Status: Closed
Issue Type: Bug Report
Project: Unofficial Skyrim Legendary Edition Patch
Component: Skyrim LE: Vanilla
Category: Magic
Assigned To: Nobody
Platform: Windows PC
Severity: Low
Votes: 0
Watching: N/A
Opened By VaultDuke on Sep 11, 2014 6:52 am
Closed By Arthmoor on Sep 15, 2014 11:47 pm
Resolution: Fixed

Issue #17365: Wall spells and their descriptions

 
WallOfFlames "Wall of Flames" [SPEL:00035D7F] uses BarrierFireConcAimed "Fire Barrier" [MGEF:0008F3ED] with a magnitude of 8. the effects destriction reads:
"Sprayed on the ground, it creates a wall of fire that does <50> points of fire damage per second."

it should be changed to
"Sprayed on the ground, it creates a wall of fire that does <mag> points of fire damage per second."
to reflect the actual damage dealt and also take modifiers into account

also it is questionable whether 8 points of damage is the correct value. it is an expert level spell and the damage should be changed to the expected value of 50, to make it more usefull than a static flames spell.

the same problem extends (<mag> and low damage) to the spells
WallOfFrost "Wall of Frost" [SPEL:00035D80]/BarrierFrostConcAimed "Frost Barrier" [MGEF:0008F3F7] and
WallOfStorms "Wall of Storms" [SPEL:00035D81]/BarrierShockConcAimed "Wall of Storms" [MGEF:000BB96F]

Comments

2 comment(s) [Closed]
Jumps-Down-Stairs said:
 
Wall spells are a bit more complicated than that. The portion of the spell that you cast directly (WallOfFlames) only has a magnitude of 8, but that only affects the damage of the spray, not the wall it creates on impact. If it hits the ground (see MAGFlamesBarrierImpactSet), it creates a hazard (either FireBarrierHazard or FireBarrierHazardDrop as necessary), which casts HazardWallofFireSpell, which has mag 20, dur 1. There's also some taper values, but the math works out to an inconsequential amount of damage (0.66), so it just seems to be there to cover the period in between casts. The hazard casts the spell with a delay of 0.3, so it should trigger every 1.3 seconds. So that's about 16 damage per second (including the taper damage), which is substantially less than 50, but more than 8.

the Frost and Shock walls appear to have identical values, except they don't have any taper. The magnitudes for HazardWallofFireSpell, HazardWallofFrostSpell, and HazardWallOfShockSpell should all probably be changed from 20 to 50. That would be in line with their magicka costs and the effects of other Expert-level spells, and should produce effects close to the magnitude stated in the description. I think it more likely that Bethesda did their math wrong (or changed the formulas without fixing the values for these spells to compensate) than that they put in the wrong value in the description.

To elaborate, the developer may have intended the spell to trigger 3 times per second (Target Interval of 0.3), which would work out to somewhere between 50 and 60 damage per second with a magnitude of 20, but did not account for Target Interval meaning a delay between effects</em> -- it doesn't cast a new effect until the previous one expires, plus the Target Interval. The developer may have assumed that the duration of the effect wasn't taken into account, or they may have initially set the duration on the effect to 0, and then realized it didn't look right once they tested it.

Comment #1 Sep 11, 2014 8:27 am  Edited by on Sep 11, 2014 8:33 am
Arthmoor said:
 
Fixed for USKP 2.0.7.

Raised the magnitudes on the 3 hazard spells to 50 from 20.

Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2